Kelly Rutherford Is the Fashion Muse We All Need

Calling All Gossip Girl Fans and Style Obsessives.

POSTED BY TASNIM MIAH

Hey, Upper East Siders! And if you're not a Gossip Girl  fan (gasp), trust me — you'll want to meet this style icon.

Now, when you hear the term "fashion muse" thrown around, names like Kate Moss or Naomi Campbell might immediately come to mind. But over the past few years, Kelly Rutherford has carved out a space for herself as a quietly influential figure in style culture. Best known for playing Lily van der Woodsen on Gossip Girl, Rutherford's personal style has evolved into something equally chic and compelling.

Three words to summarise Kelly Rutherford's wardrobe? Classy, elegant, and timeless. The aesthetic isn't loud or trend-driven; she styles pieces that are inherently wearable and scream “old-money vibes” (suddenly Lily van der Woodsen makes a lot more sense). We often hear the phrase quiet luxury time and time again, but Rutherford’s style is quite literally the epitome of it, with a dash of personal flair. She champions clean lines, quality materials, and minimalist silhouettes — oh, and of course, the occasional casual Birkin bag — that merge Parisian chic with New York cool, making her, in my book, the ultimate fashion inspiration.

What sets her apart from the style of many other celebrities is her authenticity. Rutherford documents her fits on Instagram with elevator selfies from her New York apartment. What we love most is the unfiltered glimpse we get into her personal wardrobe. It’s unedited, organic content — outfits composed of neutrals, tailored staples, statement coats, and thoughtfully curated accessories. It feels attainable yet undeniably chic.

Unlike traditional muses, Kelly's style isn't defined by a single era or designer. Her appeal lies in timelessness and elegance. Truly, I believe she's a style pioneer for anyone who believes the clothes you choose can be an extension of your identity — not just what's trending. Because, let's be honest: Kelly Rutherford's style often says a thousand words on her behalf before she even speaks.

Want to cosplay as a rich NYC mom with impeccable style? My Fizzypicks have got you covered!

WEEKDAY
Kia Oversized Wool-Blend Double-Breasted Coat
$189.00

 

THE FRANKIE SHOP
Ravello Wrap Coat
$695.00

 

ALL SAINTS
Asha High Neck Jumper
$260.00

 

COS
Ribbed-Collar Boiled Merino Wool Jacket
$169.00

 

COS
Layered Shawl Merino-Cashmere Sweater 
$329.00

 

GIVENCHY
Black Bold Glasses
$400.00

 

&OTHER STORIES
Alpaca-Blend Knitted Top
$99.00

 

REFORMATION
Val 90s Mid Rise Straight Jeans
$178.00

 

ASOS 
Funnel Neck Oversized Longline Trench Coat in Mushroom
$129.00

 

ESSENTIEL ANTWERP
Howy Fitted Jacket
$240.00

 

ASTR THE LABEL
Bellmere Jacket
$116.00

 

GANNI
Green Open Back Sweater
$272.50

 

TORY BURCH
Classic Penny Loafer 
$210.00

 

MIU MIU
Miu Regard Oval Glasses 
$460.00

 

UNIQLO
Cotton Oversized Shirt
$39.90

 

REFORMATION
Tilly Ballet Flat
$248.00

 

ZARA
Maxi Shopper With Details
$75.90

 

REFORMATION
Mason Pant 
$188.00

 

MANGO
Small Crossbody Bag
$69.99

 

ASOS
Knit Oversized Knit Cardigan With Tie Waist
$59.99

UP NEXT ON THE HITLIST
Ok